Roland also finds that Hilary Faye charged several cans of spray paint to her credit card just hours before the attack — indicating that she was the one who spray-painted the school. On their way in, Tia finds a credit-card receipt for the spray paint—signed by Hilary Faye.
When Mary, Patrick, Cassandra and Roland arrive, Hilary attempts to have Mary and Cassandra thrown out, but Pastor Skip decides to let them stay.
While searching the lockers with the Jewels looking on, Mary's homeroom teacher finds a sonogram of Mary's baby.
She tries to hide it, but it drops to the ground in front of Pastor Skip's feet.
A few months later, after multiple fights at school between Hilary Faye and Cassandra, Pastor Skip puts Roland, Cassandra and Mary on the school prom committee (chaired by Hilary Faye) to punish them.Veronica turns on Hilary as well, calling her a fake.As the now-exposed Hilary Faye flees with the others in pursuit, Dean suddenly arrives with other teenagers from Mercy House.Roland reveals that he is not really a Christian, unlike his fanatically religious sister.Cassandra reveals she is only at American Eagle after being thrown out of her old school, and decided she could "handle the freaks" at American Eagle over being home-schooled by her parents.